Monday, February 6, 2012

Peter Singer

Peter Singer is an Australian bioethics professor in London wrote an article titled Invisible Man. In this article, he argues the strains between the American citizens and the government in the never ending battle between the protection of privacy and complete transparency. Singer argues that the push of transparency from the government or "Panopticon" in other words makes the citizens extremely paranoid.  We do not know when we are being spied on, and it has become a matter of our constitutional rights. Should the government be allowed to do such a thing without probable cause or a "warrant" one might say? It is understandable that the government is just trying to prevent another terrorist attack, but at the same time, is the government losing trust in the American citizens? The  point I found most shocking was that The CIA had some information about a terrorist attack prior to September 11, but was not allowed to release the information because of laws. Well if they couldn't release the information, what makes them think we knew anything? What gives them the right to pry into our personal information? Americans have a strong sense of patriotism. We are not trying to harm the country. We just want to go about our daily lives hoping that we are being protected, but we also want to know that our private information is kept to ourselves only. Sensitive information has a right to be kept a secret, but the government feels otherwise. On the other hand the government legally is not allowed to exploit the information unless it is considered harmful to national security. The WikiLeaks page was only a problem to the government because it threatened harm to our military, but other than that, it was not worth keeping form the Americans. Peter Singer makes a great argument in the  fact that this is going to to be a never ending battle until the citizens and government can come to a compromise on how to handle the privacy issue.

No comments:

Post a Comment